Skip to main content
Christian LivingPodcastUncategorized

Finding Comfort in Suffering: A Personal Q & A on Grief and God’s Goodness – Tim Challies

image_printPrint Friendly Version

In this episode, Chap Bettis sits down with Tim Challies and pastor Travis Rymer for a candid Q & A that closes out The Disciple-Making Parent’s mini-series on suffering. Tim shares Scriptures and hymns that shaped his grief, how his family helped their daughters process loss, and why grief must never become our identity. You’ll also hear practical counsel on balancing honest lament with trust in God’s goodness, and on letting truth shape emotions rather than emotions shaping truth.

Resources From This Podcast
Tim Challies: Suffering and Our Savior (#1 in series)
Tim Challies: Personal Accounts of God’s Goodness in Suffering (#2 in series)
On Jordan’s Stormy Banks, performed by Indelible Grace
Seasons of Sorrow, by Tim Challies
A Manifesto for Times of Suffering– Tim’s “Grief Manifesto”
Dark Clouds, Deep Mercy, by Mark Vroegop
Tim Challies- Walking Through Deep Sorrow and Loss (Prior podcast interview) ​

Podcast Transcript
Chap:   I am Chap Betis and you’re listening to The Disciple-Making Parent, where we seek to equip parents and churches to pass the gospel to their children. Have you enjoyed our other recent presentations on suffering? Would you like to hear some personal interaction with Tim Challies? Well, then this podcast is for you. Hi, my name is Chap Bettis and I’m the author of The Disciple-Making Parent, and with this podcast we finish up our miniseries on suffering. This is our third podcast in the series. If you have a chance, go back and listen to the previous two podcasts where Tim talked about suffering and the savior, and also just some personal reflections on the goodness of God.

Well, in today’s podcast, you’ll listen in again to Tim as he interacts with me and my associate pastor Travis Rymer in a short Q&A time. I especially appreciated two ideas: One was not letting my suffering be my identity. I thought that was really helpful. And the second was shaping my feelings and emotions by truth and not shaping truth by my emotions. And so you’re going to want to listen to the Q&A where he talks about that. The recording comes from Tim’s recent visit to my home church in Providence, Rhode Island. The Disciple-Making Parent ministry co-sponsored a conference with the church. And you can listen to my introduction of Tim in the previous podcast for a little background.

Before we start though, I want to remind you about our newest resource, which is Managing Your Households Well. That’s a biblical requirement for pastors, deacons, and really all who aspire to leadership in God’s church. But what does that phrase mean, and why is it important? If you’re a leader or you want to be a leader or you’re married to someone who aspires to leadership, then check this book out wherever Christian books are sold. It’s Managing Your Households Well: How Family Leadership Trains You for Church Leadership. And of course, we always recommend and highlight that we give away the audio book for The Disciple-Making Parent absolutely free. We’re on a mission to equip parents and grandparents to raise children who not only love the Lord and are not only disciples, but disciple-makers, taking the gospel to the world and standing as salt and light in our country. So head on over to thedisciplemakingparent.com for your free audiobook. But for now, let’s listen in on some personal Q&A as we talk about suffering.

Travis Rymer: Alright, we’re just going to jump right in and try to make the best use of the time. The text message if you have a question that popped into your head, but one question I wanted to ask- First of all, just thank you. Thank you for coming here and sharing these things with us, and even you sharing this is one of the ways that Nick’s death is being used by God. And I’m sure you’ve thought about that, and we’ll never know the ramifications of that, but it’s encouraging for us to hear that and to know. Obviously you shared a passage from Luke to us that’s clearly been meaningful and helpful to you. One quick question was, are there other passages like that, that God really used to help you process and grieve? And even, like you said, you were taught good theology ahead of time, but in the fog of suffering, you can even forget those things.

Tim Challies: Yeah, I had the privilege of being raised in Dutch Reformed churches, and one of the things Dutch Reformed churches do very well- there’s a lot now I disagree with, but what one thing they do very well is catechizing. And so from a very young age, I was introduced to the Heidelberg Catechism. And I think most people, even Baptists like myself, as I’ve become, I would be familiar with question and answer one of the Heidelberg catechism, which is, What is your only comfort in life and death? That’s the question. And isn’t it interesting? This great theological document, 52 Lord’s days’ worth of questions and answers dealing with doctrine, begins with What is your only comfort in life and death?

I’ve read a lot of systematic theologies. Not too many of them begin with, How can you be comforted? What is your great comfort? And the answer of course is That I am not my own, but belong in body and soul, both in life and death, to my faithful savior, Jesus Christ. And that was food for me in those days. Now catechism aren’t scripture, but hopefully they’re faithful summaries of scripture. And so yeah, question and answer one of the Heidelberg Catechism was so important to me.

And of course you might know some of the songs that are written about it. The Gettys have one, Old Mars Hill Music has one. And just tremendously helpful things to think about and yeah, lots of other passages. Often just little bits of passages thinking about Paul and escaping from the shipwreck off Malta and just that little one, you know, they’re all swimming to the shore and it just says, “All were brought safely to land.” I found so much joy just thinking about here’s this tremendous shipwreck and God had promised all of you’ll reach the shore safely. And sure enough, all were brought safely to land. Thinking about the Israelites crossing the Jordan River, and which has often been used by Christians as a picture of reaching heaven. On Jordan’s Stormy Banks I Stand. I’m just thinking again about the joy of crossing over that river and being reunited there. So yeah, scripture’s been just so precious. And when you’re looking for comfort in scriptures, it’s on every page.

Travis: You said your wife kind of struggled with prayer. Was your reaction more to just dig into scripture? Was that your first reaction?

Tim: I tended to dig into sermons, so reflections on scripture is where I found real comfort. I’m a Bible reading plan guy, so I sort of kept going with my plan after a few days maybe of not being in it, but I sort of kept with my plan. But where I really found nourishment for my soul was reading sermons. So again, reflections on scripture, expositions of scripture. I sort of needed someone to do that first level of thinking for me. 

Travis: All right, Chap, you can stop me anytime, but I’m going to- 

Chap: One more. One more. 

Travis: Okay. Alright. We’re getting the benefit of hearing you after you’ve spent six years grieving and thinking and writing and I’m just sitting there as I’m listening to your purpose statement, and there was a lot of meaty content in your it. Each line. How long in grieving did it take you to write that and then- maybe this is sort of a cheeky question, but how long to live that, right? It’s one thing to heart and mind try to get there, but it’s another thing to start. 

Chap: And where is that? That’s in Seasons of Sorrow? 

Tim: Yeah. So the Grief Manifesto, it’s in Seasons of Sorrow. I also put it out on my website because I thought some people want to copy and paste it and then just modify it, make it your own. I think for some people that’s helpful. I’ve written a few books now and you always wait for feedback on your books. It’s going to come whether you like it or not. And I once wrote a book and the very first feedback I got was somebody saying, “I just want you to know, this is the worst book I’ve ever read. Your book is so bad I think it would only be fair and just if you contacted the publisher and they offered refunds to everybody who’s ever bought that book.” That felt great. With Seasons of Sorrow, the very first feedback I ever got from somebody was, “I read your book and then I came to the Grief Manifesto, and I think that is such an abhorrent thing to include in a book. I would never, ever recommend your book to anybody.” And sort of along those same lines. 

And yet the most positive feedback I’ve gotten from Seasons of Sorrow in the end has been, I think, about the Grief Manifesto. Because people who I think want to grieve theologically, if you will, who want to really praise God through their sorrow or honor God through their sorrow, just found what I’ve done there is to kind of collect all this good stuff from people who have grieved in the past and use that as putting parameters on their grief. So it’s available on my website if you want to kind of personalize it and make it your own, because it reflects mine but it might not reflect everybody’s. 

Travis: And so how long did it take you to put that together? 

Tim: I think that I wrote that about maybe six or eight months in. And it was sort of just taking all those thoughts and collecting them and I hope I’ll live it out. My family’s sort of taking it as our thing, and I go back to it fairly frequently and just make sure it’s still describing, best as the Lord enables, what I’m doing, how I’m living. 

Chap: Okay, I’m going to break in. I wish I could ask all these, but I can’t. I’m sorry. 

Tim: Have you ever gotten feedback like that on one of your books before?

 Travis: I’ve been wanting to talk to you, Chap. 

Tim: All right, carry on. 

Travis: I didn’t have the courage till now. No, I’m just kidding. 

Chap: Grace Harbor is very sweet, so I will say no. I have not, thank the Lord. I think I’d crawl into a hole after that. So. Whoo. Now I’ve lost my place. Here’s one: What particular ways did you help your other children work through things? 

Tim: So our daughters had a shared loss, but a different experience of it. So Abby was present with Nick when he died. Nick was her favorite person, and she watched her brother die. That that was a very, very traumatic thing for her. So Abby really needed some counseling. She had really some PTSD-type effects from it. She was having panic attacks and other things, and so thankfully, at Boyce College, there was counseling available to her and to the other students who were there. It really was traumatizing, and that really helped her and gave her the tools to be able to work through what had happened. And to be able to know how to respond to panic attacks. 

Another thing, Michaela was not there. She was at home with us. So she lost a brother she loved as well, but for her it was more living in a home with parents during COVID when we were walked down for months at a time, with parents are just not functioning very well. And so I think for her it was more, I don’t want to say abandonment, but that might be sort of how she felt. And just the absence of parents in her hardest time. And so what we tried to do was involve some of the young women, older women than her, but young women in the church just being present in her life, and I think that was very meaningful to her. In fact, two of those, Michaela’s getting married in May, and one of them is in her wedding party and the other is going to be at the wedding. These young ladies who are about 10 years older than her who just very present and very comforting to her. So we’re so thankful for the local church and its ministry to our family. 

Chap: How does someone suffering maintain the balance between honest lament and crossing over into sinful anger? 

Tim: Mmmm. Yeah. We have no right to accuse God of wrong, no right to think that God’s plans for this world are even second best. So I think we’re living in the best version of our lives that that could be. So what comes our way isn’t. . . God isn’t just responding to things that happen out there and making the best of a bad situation. I think we can really believe that in some way, God receives more glory through this life than any other. We can still express our sorrow that there is grief in this world, that there is pain and loss in this world, but we can never impugn the character of God. We can never accuse God of having done wrong. We can never accuse him of having let us down or anything else. 

Because of some writing in the Christian world, lament has become formal. Lament has become very, I think, prominent right now in the Christian world. A lot of people have read Dark Clouds, Deep Mercy by Mark Vroegop, and it’s a very good book. We didn’t feel the need to do that kind of lament, and I know it’s been very helpful to some people we’ve walked through that with.  We’ve had a lot of parents we’ve walked through grief with now, people who’ve come alongside or come alongside us. For some of them that’s been very helpful. For us, we didn’t find it that helpful to go through some of the Psalms of lament like he does and make them our own. That just wasn’t our form of grieving, for whatever that’s worth. But if that is important to you, I think his book puts good parameters on it. Go with that. 

Chap: So now, and we’re dealing with emotions, what does joy in those trials look like? What did that look like for you? Maybe for Aileen, how does that look? 

Tim: We didn’t think God wanted us to not enjoy the joys that he gives us. Now, obviously for a time, it’s hard to find a lot of joy in life when you’re really deeply sorrowful. But we know that God gives us joys and means for us to enjoy them, to make the most of them. So pretty quickly, we wanted to experience beauty and appreciate beauty. Right after the funeral, we went to the airport and flew out to Banff National Park in Alberta. We just needed to be where it was beautiful. We needed to be near mountains, just to realize our own smallness compared to God, et cetera. It’s hard to stand before a mountain and think great thoughts about yourself, right? You want to praise the maker of the mountains. We just felt we had this responsibility to continue to enjoy the joys in life. And so you find you can grieve and rejoice at the same time. Those two things don’t cancel each other out, so you’re genuinely sad and genuinely rejoicing at the same time. And I think God enabled us to, to do both. 

Chap: Can we do one more? Can you repeat what you said about feelings, and truth guiding that? Because I’m wondering if that’s just the air we breathe- I’m a victim and the feelings are king. 

Tim: This was especially important for Aileen, I think, to not allow truth to be subjected to her feelings. So to change what she believes because of what she feels. Rather, it was important for her to take her feelings and subject them to truth to make sure that truth was informing her feelings. So if she felt God didn’t love her by taking her son, she had to say No, I might feel that, but I know what’s true, which is God loves me and God loves Nick and God isn’t punishing me or anything like that. So just constantly making sure that truth reigns over feelings. 

Feelings are good, emotion is good. These aren’t bad gifts, but they’re subject to the fall and they can be misused. And I think, especially culturally right now, we believe that that feelings surpass truth, are greater than truth and more reliable than truth. And so it’s just important to her, especially, to keep making sure that truth was informing her emotions. Otherwise she might have been carried away with them. 

Chap: That’s even a commitment before we come into grief. Before this happens, my feelings will be subject to truth.

Travis: So this is a good, perhaps, follow up to that. But you had talked about in your five lessons of grief, one of them is just people grieve differently. So we need to give people room to grieve according to their personality. I wonder if maybe you could speak to that in conjunction with how sometimes we can grieve in a way that grief becomes our close friend and, and it becomes something that people aren’t even allowed to touch. Because you don’t understand my grief and my grief is very different. You’ll never understand. And it’s a way to, in some ways, maybe to hold on to grief. Did you experience that? And can you talk about that at all?

Tim: Yeah. One of my temptations in life is to kind of feel sorry for myself. And I realized pretty early on that because of that, grief could quickly become my identity. And so it might be that you barely know me, but the one thing I need you to know about me is I lost my son. I’m a grieving person. That feels like it gives me power over people or something, right? I’m sorrowful, I’m grieving, therefore you can’t treat me this way. Or something like that. So I realized that could be a temptation. And I really didn’t want grief to become my identity. I have an identity and it’s better than that; my identity’s in Christ. And so that’s not denying that grief has shaped me and that it’s a constant presence in my life, but it makes a very poor identity.

I think there’s, there’s a lot of different ways that we can form our identity by our circumstances. If you experience chronic pain, then maybe that’s the thing people are going to know about you. There can be all sorts of things that you’ve suffered- abuse, all sorts of things- that are difficult circumstances in our life and are truly grievous and we need to work out before the Lord, but they can’t become our identity. Because then they start to take away from our true identity, which is in Christ. 

Travis: Quick follow-up: If I’m somebody who’s struggling with that, perhaps I feel like struggling with having my identity in my suffering, perhaps one of the things I’m going to struggle to do in order to take your counsel is, I might feel like I’m giving it up. Like you said, someone fears that the person that they lose will be forgotten. I can imagine I’m afraid that I’m allowing that, or I’ll forget, or I’m living as though that person is gone, forgotten. Does that make any sense? What would you say to me if that’s me?

Tim: I’m not sure what the question is. 

Travis: if I hear you and that rings true, and I myself am struggling to respond with identity in Christ as my primary identity, but instead grief. Maybe as you’re saying this, I’m recognizing, Oh, that is me. What would you say to me as I try to move out of that? Is maybe a different way to put it.

Chap: Or maybe because you are an elder, you do you help people who perhaps need that to be said to them? Yes, there is a time. But as a pastor, not at this church, I had a parishioner and losing his young wife became his identity.

Tim: I think when that happens, you become a slave to that identity, right? You lose your primary identity sense of self, who you really are, which is a follower of Christ. I am in Christ. That is my deepest identity. But there’s always going to be things competing for that. The thing that you want people to know about yourself most, or the thing that most defines you. And so just leading people toward Christ. There is no greater identity or deeper identity than that. And once you align yourself with Christ, that is who I am, then all the other things can take their proper place. So that becomes part of your story. It becomes part of your calling from God, part of who you are, but it doesn’t become the main thing about you. 

Chap: That’s good. Yeah, I think that’s good. I’d love to go on, but I think we need to end. Why don’t you pray for our time, and then we’ll close with the final song.

Travis: Father, we thank you. Thank you for the testimony that Tim brings us, that reminds us of your goodness, your good purposes. The call to accept that the life that we’re living, the life that you’ve given us is part of your good purpose and this is the best life that you’ve designed for us, Lord. That’s a hard thing perhaps, especially in grieving, to embrace, but it’s also a really powerful and freeing thing if we could do that. So, Lord, we pray for grace, grace for one another, but grace, Lord, to embrace maybe some of the things that we’re hearing from Tim, maybe for the first time or that are just really helpful to us. God, we ask that you would give us much to think about as we keep meditating on these things and bless our time tomorrow, we ask in Jesus’ name. Amen. 

Chap: Thank you for listening to The Disciple-Making Parent podcast. We love creating free content for you, but we can only do that because of our financial partners, men and women who understand the ministry, believe in it, and want to invest in it. So would you join us? We literally can’t do even this podcast without you. So to leave a legacy for the next generation, head on over to thedisciplemaking parent.com/partner.

image_printPrint Friendly Version